Home > Settlements > Wells Fargo Ordered to Pay $203M in Overdraft Fees Class Action Settlement
Wells Fargo Ordered to Pay $203M in Overdraft Fees Class Action Settlement
May 16 2013
San Francisco, CA: US District Judge William Alsup has issued an order to reinstate a $203 million judgment against Wells Fargo Bank. The judgment is based upon the court's findings, as affirmed on appeal by the Ninth Circuit, that Wells Fargo violated California's unfair competition law by deceiving its customers that debit card purchases would be posted chronologically to their accounts when in fact Wells Fargo posted them in a high-to-low order for the sole purpose of generating overdraft fees.
The case before Judge Alsup was brought on behalf of California Wells Fargo customers who, from November 15, 2004 to June 30, 2008, incurred overdraft fees on debit card transactions as a result of the bank's practice of sequencing transactions from highest to lowest.
On August 10, 2010, Judge Alsup issued a 90-page opinion finding that Wells Fargo manipulated its processing of customer debit card purchases by its California customers, and made misleading statements to consumers regarding is resequencing practice, to maximize overdraft fees in violation of California's Unfair Competition Law. This practice had the greatest impact on the bank's low income customers because their accounts often had the smallest balances.
As noted above, instead of posting transaction chronologically, Wells Fargo deducted the largest charges first, drawing down available balances more rapidly and triggering a higher volume of overdraft fees. Judge Alsup ordered that Wells Fargo return to its customers approximately $203 million in restitution and enjoined the abusive accounting practices. Judge Alsup's August 10, 2010, decision followed two and half years of extended litigation that culminated in a two-week bench trial which ended in May 2010.
On September 9, 2010, Wells Fargo filed an appeal with the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. On December 26, 2012, the appellate court issued an opinion upholding and reversing portions of Judge Alsup's order, and remanded the case to the district court for further proceedings.
The appellate court found the National Bank Act preempted application of state law to Wells Fargo's decision to use high-to-low posting. Importantly, the appellate court also found that false and misleading statements by Wells Fargo were not preempted and the bank could be held liable for affirmative misrepresentations in violation of California's Unfair Competition Law.
In his decision, Judge Alsup reinstated the judgment against Wells Fargo, finding: "This order is not penalizing Wells Fargo for a practice protected by federal preemption. Instead, it is penalizing Wells Fargo for affirmatively misleading the class as to what the practice was, namely engaging in a practice likely to mislead the class to believe that processing would be done in chronological order when, in fact, processing was done in high-to-low, non-chronological order."
I told "Jasmine" 2 months ago to close my account.
I am being charged OD charges ond being told they have paid things to this date Jan 12, 2017!
I had my Direct Deposit stopped.
Posted by Matthew T.
We have auto deposit and every mo there is $400 to $ 500 in overdrafts. They changed the order of charges to have the larger charge first get deposited. Has even withheld the charge for a day or two giving you a false balance if you check it on line. I have a statement that shows Wells Fargo charging me a OD fee with a positive balance. Wells Fargo also randomly transfers savings to checking using up your one a month OD protection for free to charge $12.50 the next time. In one year, (2015 to 2016) because of Identity theft had to change to another Acct (4 in 2 Years). Wells Fargo charged over $4000.00 just in fees. We are on SSI and only have $900 a mo coming in. Today on Xmas we lost the this fight and our house. Today's balance is -$504.00 without a gift to the kids bought. One bank reported making around $6 Billion on OD fees in one year by stealing from the poor. If you made $6 billion just in fees for 1 year and got a penalty of $200 million after 6 years in court, Would you stop doing that practice if you got away with $35.8 billion clean and clear? Quit thinking that $200 million was something large in scale. It's big to all of us but only a very small percent. think of it like this $200 out of $36,000.00. Way to sell us short.....
Posted by Colandra Nathan
i had wells fargo a while back charged me a arm and a leg in overdraft fees plz tell me how to proceed
Posted by CONSUELO JAMES
THIS WAS DONE TO ME ALSO,WITH OUT MY CONSENT.I WAS SERVERLY CHARGED FOR OVER DRAFT PROTECTION ......
Posted by Clementine Washington
I had open an account with them and they repeatedly subtracted sums of money from my accounts. I called them so many times I finally gave up as by then all my money was gone. I took sick and ........... I just saw where lawsuits against Well Fargo.I would like to ask if I can be reimbursed for all the money taken.
Posted by Rose Littlefoot
Had an account from 2008 until 2015, never heard about a lawsuit. But not sure if anything is owed.
Posted by William
I had closed and account at a branch or thought the account was closed but they continued to withdraw money every 6 months to the account that was 'overdrawn' for a 'set off' even though it was closed and did not appear on any of my statements. I have been a customer of Wells Fargo for over 18 years and also did not get any information about an of the class action lawsuits, can we file something since I have read a few of the comments and have the same thing happen to them?
Posted by steph A.
This is continuing to happen to me today, even if I put money in they do the charge before my money deposit. Also they chronological order is always off.
Posted by robert krilich
I was charged $6230.00 in overdraft fees from PNC bank in 2015, Do I have any recourse on this?
Posted by Rachel Boyko
Overdraft fees are not a good thing when its not even fair due to your mistakes.
Posted by Lorrie
Experienced the same thing as Gail above in the state of TX in one day they over drafted me 9 times. At one point I closed or thought the account was closed but they continued to withdraw money.
Posted by Jennifer
My boyfriend had an account with Wells Fargo back in 2012-2013, we had similar issues with his account . It was like everytime we turned around we had a negative balance from that overdraft trick. we were never notified of a class action suit. We have moved a few times and during moving we don't usually hang on to paperwork for long. So what do we do on this to be part of the suut.
Posted by Doris Wright
I was a Wells Fargo Banking Customer from 2006-2010 and was never notified of this lawsuit, nor did I receive a check. Was there a certain year that you had to be a customer in order to be apart of this lawsuit?
Posted by Michael Terry
If you feel you have been cheated at least $200 by your bank or credit union, write a letter and include evidence and send it to: U.S. Treasury, Comptroller of the Currency---Google for the rest of the address.
Posted by Rebecca Ray
I believe I should be a oart of this law suit.
How do I pursuit it?
Posted by Lesley Gomez
I have been a customer of Wells Fargo since 2008. Why was I not notified of this. Are all Wells Fargo customers who have been with them on or before 2008 included? Also Wells Fargo has continued to reorganize purchases using different excuses up to and including last month. They always reorganize and hit the small amounts with overdrafts 3 or 4 even though the small items were charged first and the large amount last. When forced to give up time stamp on the actual charges they change their story. They have their employees well trained. Most of them you can get a few to slip up in the story but then a supervisor gets on, apologizes for the miss information and gives you the story that is in their best interest. It's amazing
Posted by Al
Is not only WF it's every Bank and credit union. They use the same tactics and manipulate deposits and withdrawals at will and overdraft fees pile up. I was recently charged $25.00 each for two deposits (0.33 and another for $0.49) made on my account not honored by my CU because they claim I had defaulted on my LOC and my money in the account could not be used for deposits or withdrawals. It's mind boggling on how they can away with this!
Posted by Nichol
About time they are always doing this to me
Posted by Tina Dreis
I can relate to everyone above and this situation. Not only have I tried our local bank and the 1-800 number of Wells Fargo both being met with hostility and rudeness and to the point of them calling me a deadbeat. I am wondering if anybody who reads this knows of any ongoing class action suit regarding their overuse of fees and manipulation of accounts. This is published in February 2016 thank you very much for any help you can offer.
Posted by John Ferguson
We've had numerous overdraft fees.
Posted by Gail
About time! They did this to me repeatedly, in TEXAS and also , after refunding a disputed withdrawal, finding in my favor, they waited until I wrote checks against the refund THEY GAVE ME BASED ON MY CLAIM, THEN SUDDENLY, WITH NO NOTICE, WITHDREW IT AGAIN, CAUSING MY ACCOUNT TO BE OVERDRAWN AND THEN CHARGED A TON OF FEES FOR THAT!! WHEN I ASKED WHY, THEY SAID THEY CHANGED THEIR MINDS ABOUT THE CLAIM THEY APPROVED. TOTAL DELIBERATE CRAP! I COULD HAVE PAID IT OFF (197 $$ TOTAL) A HUNDRED TIMES BY NOW, BUT REFUS3D TO ON PRINCIPAL. I WILL NEVER USE THAT CROOKED BANK AGAIN! THE ORDER I WROTE CH3CKS NEVER OVERDRAFTED ME, BECAUSE I ALWAYS PUT IN ENOUGH TO COVER THINGS, BUT THEY TOOK HIGHEST AMOUNT FIRST AND DEPOSITS ADDED LAST, SO I WAS OVERDRAWN QUITE A FEW TIMES...ALL IN TEXAS, BACK IN 2001 TO 2002. STILL ANGRY OVER THAT CRAP!
Posted by Heather
Wells Fargo charged me close to $2000.00 in overdraft fees
Posted by Virginia
Manipulating processing of my debit card purchases, as they did in the California lawsuit. Drawing down available balances rapidly, triggering high volumes of overdraft fees, creating more overdraft fees by generating them against a low balance.
Add Your Comment on This Issue
Request Legal Help
Please complete this form to request a review of your complaint by an attorney.
There is absolutely no cost to you to submit this form. Doing so places you under no obligations and does not establish an attorney-client relationship.